BindCommands Problem

ImScheinox · 2025-06-18T12:53:55.890Z

I'm using BindCommands in 1.21.5 and if I set open command to key H I'm unable to open it. When I disable BindCommands it works again. These are my BindCommands: key.keyboard.left.alt="/equipment" key.keyboard.p="/pet" key.keyboard.r="/wardrobe"

Started by ImScheinox18 June 202576 replies

18 June 2025
ImScheinox12:53
I'm using BindCommands in 1.21.5 and if I set open command to key H I'm unable to open it. When I disable BindCommands it works again. These are my BindCommands: key.keyboard.left.alt="/equipment" key.keyboard.p="/pet" key.keyboard.r="/wardrobe"(edited)
I don't see any reason why it should interfere at all!
ImScheinox13:07
reinstalled the whole mod and it worked again: Update it occured again so I'm still clueless(edited)
ImScheinox13:40
🧐
kalucky0Team16:44
What is "Open Command"?
I would like to know what you are trying to achieve. Setting "Open Command" to H should send a chat message with that content when H is pressed.
ImScheinox17:07
Replying tokalucky0What is "Open Command"?
open command is a vanilla keybind
kalucky0Team17:07
I don't understand
Oh ok
ImScheinox17:08
kalucky0Team17:08
This makes sense
I thought I already fixed that
ImScheinox17:10
but its only when I set it to H, if I set it to V for example its working. but I have it on H for 6+ years and would like to keep it that way xD
kalucky0Team17:11
The weird thing is that BindCommands doesn't touch the vanilla bindings code at all
ImScheinox17:12
if I remove the mod its working again
so I thought it conflicts with the mod
im some weird way
kalucky0Team17:12
it probably does because it's not the first time this is reported
do you have any other mods?
ImScheinox17:13
Replying tokalucky0do you have any other mods?
yeah the usual fabric performance mods
so a lot
kalucky0Team17:14
let me try to build a 1.7.0 version for 1.21.5
ImScheinox17:15
bec I haven't found another 1.21.5 fabric mod that let me do the same
kalucky0Team17:17
try this
fabric-bind-cmd-1.7.0-1.21.5.jarJava archive, 56 KB. Not stored in the archive.
ImScheinox17:18
I'll try
kalucky0Team17:18
In 1.7.0 I rewritten almost the whole mod so maybe whatever was causing the issue was removed
ImScheinox17:23
game is starting
hm okay youre not gonna like it
on the first try it worked fine but I made a game restart to see if its consistent(edited)
but it wasn't working after the restart
ImScheinox17:31
Replying toImScheinoxon the first try it worked fine but I made a game restart to see if its consistent
but thats the same behaviour with the official 1.21 version. If I reinstall it its gonna work as long as im not restarting the game
K
kalucky0Team20:31
I'll try to reproduce this tomorrow
- ❤️1
That's such a hard to catch bug
I have no idea what could be causing that
kalucky0Team20:49
If you can try to list step by step what you did and what happened so that I can try to do the same
Time to do some detective work
ImScheinox22:27
Sure 1: install the mod launch the game. Set open command to H in the vanilla mc control settings. open bindcommands config, delete the h for /help and set some custom commands. quit the game and 2. restart the game, boom isn't working anymore
19 June 2025
kalucky0Team14:42
Oh
I think I know what the problem is(edited)
ImScheinox14:54
a problem on my side or mod problem?
kalucky0Team15:05
mod
I think when you remove a binding it overrides the vanilla one too(edited)
kalucky0Team15:14
I need to analyze how Minecraft handles input
kalucky0Team15:46
I think I fixed the issue
@ImScheinox try this
fabric-bind-cmd-1.7.1-rc.1-1.21.5.jarJava archive, 56 KB. Not stored in the archive.
You'll need to add a command under "H" and then remove it
This should remove the binding
And unlock the "H" key for the "Open Command" binding
I
ImScheinox15:51
thanks, I will try it soon
- 1
kalucky0Team15:51
Great
ImScheinox16:14
okay I tested it
its a temporary fix
but you have to do it still after every game restart
ImScheinox16:15
Replying tokalucky0And unlock the "H" key for the "Open Command" binding
or do you mean I have to remove the h key for open command temporary while doing all this?
kalucky0Team16:17
It should work like this: - There is a "ghost" keybind from the mod - You add a new keybind with the ghost key - You remove it - This removes it permanently from Minecraft settings
You might need to reassign H to the vanilla binding I'm not sure
ImScheinox16:22
I still only get it to work if I add and remove it every time I start the game hm
I could stream it to you
kalucky0Team16:24
That won't be neccessary I have the same behaviour
I guess I need to call some function that will save these changes
ImScheinox16:37
its a pretty rare/unique bug tbh, so idk if a fix is needed, but I would appreciate it. I found another mod that works for me but it has a worse UI
So I would like to keep your version
kalucky0Team16:49
Can you share your options.txt?(edited)
ImScheinox16:53
options.txtText file, 7 KB. Not stored in the archive.
kalucky0Team16:56
oh god
no... that's...
so stupid
ImScheinox17:00
👀
kalucky0Team17:02
You might be one of the only people who had this exact problem, because H is the default "example command" it's being registered every time the mod is ran, even after you remove it
ImScheinox17:03
oh I see
kalucky0Team17:05
try this
fabric-bind-cmd-1.7.1-rc.2-1.21.5.jarJava archive, 56 KB. Not stored in the archive.
it works for me
ImScheinox17:08
that version works
thank you very much 🙂
K
kalucky0Team17:10
Great
17:10
Time to publish an update
- ❤️1
I
ImScheinox17:13
I'm used to finding bugs and try to replicate it xD
- 1

Related threads